Thursday, September 18, 2008

'Very hard for us' - Dalai Lama and religious freedom

Taken from Cincinnati City Beat

Tibet Fest supports endangered tradition
BY Gregory Flannery | Posted 09/18/2008

Kuten Lama, who teaches at the Tibetan Buddhist monastery in Colerain Township, hosts Tibet Fest this weekend in Clifton.

When the Dalai Lama fled persecution, he found refuge in India. But where do people persecuted by the Dalai Lama go? Cincinnati.

This weekend the monks of Gaden Samdrupling (GSL) Buddhist Monastery will serve Tibetan cuisine, exhibit elaborate hand-painted silks (thangkas) and talk about peace at Tibet Fest, a two-day celebration at the Clifton Cultural Arts Center. Proceeds benefit a spiritual lineage that's under threat of extinction.

These refugees from a most unlikely oppressor -- the Dalai Lama, a Nobel Peace Prize winner -- have found a home in a most unlikely setting. GSL is less than a mile from the hyper-suburban sprawl of Colerain Avenue, a proximity belied by the quietude that reigns over the 8.5-acre monastery.

Given the pressure the GSL monks have faced, a festival might seem surprising. But that hints at the very point that the monks want to make: You can't find peace by trying to change your enemies.

"The true enemy is in ourselves," says Kuten Lama, resident teacher at GSL.

"In our delusions is the true enemy. If you want to defeat the enemy, you need to defeat your delusions and anger."

'Very hard for us'

Myths about the Dalai Lama abound in the West. He is not, in fact, the head of Buddhism around the world; he isn't even the head of Tibetan Buddhism. Before the Chinese invasion, he didn't preside over Shangri-la; Tibet was a feudal society, a place of extreme poverty ruled by a theocracy supported by a wealthy nobility.

While the Dalai Lama smiles beatifically, his policies as head of the Tibetan Government in Exile have suppressed religious freedom.

At issue is a devotional practice the Dalai Lama once followed but has now decided to stamp out. This involves honoring Dorje Shugden, a wisdom Buddha who is an important part of the lineage that GSL Monastery and millions of Tibetans follow.

The Dalai Lama hasn't simply discouraged honoring Dorje Shugden. Declaring the deity an evil spirit, he's vowed to crush the tradition.

The Tibetan Government in Exile denies identity cards to Tibetan nationals who refuse to sign oaths renouncing the deity, leaving them unable to travel, hold jobs or receive aid, according to Lisa Farnsworth, a law professor at Indiana University. Monks who hold fast to their loyalty to Dorje Shugden have been expelled from monasteries, she says, and others have been denied food or barred from participating in prayer rituals.

"We're talking about basic human rights -- being able to eat, being able to have housing, (not) having your life threatened," Farnsworth says. "You can talk about love and compassion all you want, but people are being hurt by the Dalai Lama's actions."

The issue attracted attention earlier this summer when a crowd leaving the Dalai Lama's lecture in New York City started heckling Dorje Shugden followers who held signs saying, "Dalai Lama, Give Us Religious Freedom." Police officers urged the protesters to leave the scene for their own safety.

"There were 50 police officers there who said, 'We can't protect you. You've got to get on the buses and get out of here,' " Farnsworth says.

Farnsworth is a lay student at Dagom Tensung Ling Monastery in Bloomington, Ind., GSL's "sister" monastery.

"There was one primary reason why we established our monastery: to preserve our lineage," Kuten Lama says. "The hardship is because (the Dalai Lama) took our religious freedom, our human rights. But it is very hard for us ordinary persons to explain to the world because he is so powerful and famous and our words are not too important."

Taming the monkey

The spirituality and culture that GSL will celebrate this weekend at Tibet Fest are rich in color and flavor. The monks prepare the meals, featuring Tibetan vegetables, noodle threads and momos.

"Momos are dumplings with meat or with potatoes and cheese, but it tastes different from the dumplings that you get in Chinese restaurants," says Jamyang Lama, a monk, translator and teacher at GSL. "They contain secret Tibetan spices and a lot of love."

The festival includes a photography exhibition documenting a 2007 pilgrimage to Mongolia by monks and students from Cincinnati and Bloomington. The photos of shrines in the Gobi desert, like the prayer room at GSL, capture something of the paradox of Buddhism -- a tradition that employs an intricate iconography while holding that all phenomena are essentially empty.

"Tibetan culture is very intricate, very ancient, very colorful and very symbolic," Jamyang Lama says. "The most important is how art and culture connects with the mind and happiness. When you study the Tibetan culture and heritage, you learn how to cultivate happiness and be kind."

The festival includes lectures such as "Taming Monkey Mind."

"'Monkey mind' is a metaphor," Jamyang Lama says. "Our mind is like a monkey, always jumping and striking things. It never sits still. In this lecture, we talk about meditation so everything you do can be more productive and beneficial."

Tibet Fest is part of a fundraising effort for construction of a new monastery in traditional Tibetan architectural style. Students at UC's College of Design, Architecture, Art and Planning helped create the concept for the new building.

The expansion bodes well for a lineage experiencing a double persecution.

"We are hoping to build a monastery and heritage center that will be a great asset to Cincinnati," Jamyang Lama says. "It will be very special for the city because there are few cities in this country that have this kind of presence. There is a growing interest in studying our beliefs and traditions in the community. Therefore our space in the monastery is too small."

TIBET FEST will be held 10 a.m.-5 p.m. Saturday and Sunday at the Clifton Cultural Arts Center, 3711 Clifton Ave. Admission is free.


Anonymous said...

By practitioner USA

If you check, the people supporting the Dalai Lama on this issue have put themselves in the position where they need to justify the harm being done to the Dorje Shugden practitioners. So they say they are violent, terrorists, fundamentalists, cultish, etc. If you examine carefully these are being voiced as justifications of the actions being taken by many Tibetans including the Dalai Lama to get rid of the practice (and implicitly people holding onto the practice).

If we analyze the great tragedies of persecution and marginalization that have occurred in recent history they are often performed in the name of what is morally expedient and the actions are justified by demonizing the victims as somehow deserving of the harm done. If you check the truth of these words you will see that is exactly what the anti-Dorje Shugden people are saying on various blogs around the Internet...

Its time to stop reasoning from madness. If you consider yourself a Buddhist how can you harm others?

The most entertaining aspect of this debate is watching the fanatical criticism of anyone who is speaking up about these unethical actions... Just for protesting, writing letters, blogging, etc they are being called cult members, fanatical, chinese agents, and incapable of independent thought. I have news for you -- nobody is being harmed by the WSS protests. Going and holding signs isn't creating turmoil. However if you talk to Tibetans in the USA about what is going on with the signature campaign you will find this is not a 300 year old problem. It's a ten year old problem and the Dalai Lama is causing far worse division within the Tibetan community now with his speech than has ever existed with respect to this issue ever before.

It doesn't matter how many lamas agree with the Dalai Lama; what's being done isn't right.

Anonymous said...

The Dalia Lama only takes what we let him take from us.
The merging of Western And Asians Practioners has taken little time, to become One Voice.
Dedicated to Preseving the Teachings of Lord Buddha.

Confederation Of Vajra Warriors

Kuten Lama says. "The hardship is because (the Dalai Lama) took our religious freedom, our human rights. But it is very hard for us ordinary persons to explain to the world because he is so powerful and famous and our words are not too important."
Most important has been that, "Our Words are Infintely More Important than one man's word alone.
This man's words are only as important, as We Empower Them to Be.
The lessons that the West has taught the East. Is that each and every one of our voices are equally important as that of one voice.
"United We Stand,
Divided, We Fall".
No longer do our Brethern need to fear the likes of this cheap imitation and poor substitue for a Buddha. Who portrays himself as a holy being,known as the Dalia Lama. A title given to a ruthless and viscious War Lord [5th dalia lama],for slaughtering his own people and saved the Mongols the trouble pf doing it all alone.
Our words are more importnt than his, because we speak for millions.
He represents only the devisive aristocrat refugees and the ignorant. All of whom, cower as children terified by a nightmnare. After hundreds of years of complete oppression and cruelty, equal to anything found in the Annals of African Black Slavers sagas.
Each of us is empowered to Freedom Of Speech and Freedom Of Religion to voice our Beliefs Without the Likes of The Two-Bit Usurper, known as the Dalia Lama.
No Fear! Shout it out! Your Words are Very Important to Reveal this Charlatan that deceives and lies to the World.
He is not a Buddhist!
Let alone a Buddha.
Only, a Man wearing Robes,
Who is lying to Everyone!
Stop Your hypocrisy and Deceit!
Step Down from your Throne,
Leave Us Alone!
Somebody must Change!
It's a New Day!
Turn the Wheel!
The West is the Best!
Dharma Thrives,
Bill Of Right,
Make It Right!
Your Words are Important,
Very Important!

Thom said...

i will not post, if it bothers you.

Wisdomsword said...

Thom, do post. You have important information to share from personal experience. Perhaps, though, could you keep your comments a little shorter and less long-winded?! I certainly mean no offence -- I have read your comments all over the place and like most of them -- I am just trying to keep comments on this blog a little shorter and as factual as possible, so we can build up an archive.